Government Gives Green Lights to Kill Migrants
Labelling declining bird species as resident or migrant, to allow their continued hunting, is both a shocking and short-sighted strategy.

Image 1 - Man shooting by Jake Forsher
You may have noticed that the recent consultation called Improving Protection for Huntable Wild Birds (1) has been in our crosshairs. It was a consultation that just kept giving. And not in a good way. Today, we are targeting how the government values resident birds over migrating birds of the same species. If you are questioning how hunters can tell the difference, you would be asking the right question.
The government’s primary objective with this consultation seemed to be keeping birds on Schedule 2.1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (2). Or, as we call it, the Kill List. Just a quick reminder that Schedule 2.1 is a list of birds that hunters can kill in a designated open season. Of the 9 species covered in the consultation, the government proposed removing only two species from the Kill List across all three countries (England, Scotland, Wales).
The consultation, which reflected the Governments’ proposals, suggested maintaining or extending the closed season of 7 birds. There has been much government fanfare about how wonderful this is. But shooting a Red or Amber Listed species for less time is a dismal solution to preventing their demise.
Migrants Don’t Matter
Ok, so the title might be a little inflammatory, but for those who love birds, it is 100% accurate. The Governments make it clear that migrant birds are worth less than their identical resident counterparts. Below are a few examples, and the government’s mind-blowing reasoning.
Goldeneye
The goldeneye is a Red Listed species under BoCC5 (3) and, according to the consultation (4), they are listed as Vulnerable to extinction on the GB IUCN. The consultation noted “a 58% decline in the UK wintering population since the early 1990s, with marked declines also recorded in England (41% between 1997/98 and 2022/23) and Wales (55% between 1995/96 to 2020/21)”. The majority of the remaining breeding birds are in Scotland. That was a pitiful “200 breeding females in 2010”.

Image 2 - Goldeneye by Marko Hankkila
Any rational country would remove the Goldeneye from the Kill List. But Scotland suggests extending the closed season to the 30th of September, as this “would reduce the risk of resident birds being shot before the arrival of the migrant population”. You genuinely cannot make this up!
For clarification, N. J. Aebischer's 2019 research (5) estimates 450 goldeneyes were shot in the UK in 2016. But Scotland is happy to carry on killing them, as they are more likely to be migrants. Even though they only have 200 breeding females.
Let’s sidestep the moral implications of their proposal, as that is a whole other soapbox rant. Let’s focus on this from a conservation perspective. The UK government are literally saying that killing migrant goldeneyes is somebody else’s problem. With no thought to the bigger picture. Without this joined-up thinking, it puts any species that crosses international borders at risk.
With the Office for Environmental Protection recently announcing (6) that Defra and Natural England are failing in their legal duties to protect wild birds, this should be something that they should be considering.
Pintail Virtue Signalling
The Pintail faces an even more dire situation with fewer than 30 breeding pairs nationally. Twenty-eight of those are in Scotland. They are classified as critically endangered on the IUCN GB Red List and Amber on the BoCC5 list (3). So it might surprise you to know that both Scotland and Wales want to extend the ‘close’ season. This means continuing to shoot them. Just for less time.

Image 3 - Pintail by Daniil Komov
Come wintertime, the UK receives 22,000 migrant pintails. These are not big numbers when we are talking about the survival of a species, but Scotland and Wales are using this as an excuse to carry on killing. They want to “ensure that shooting pressure, where it occurs, falls during the period when the population is dominated by continental migrants rather than native breeders” (4). Thus creating a problem for Iceland, Fennoscandia and western Siberia, where these birds originate.
Only the government can hold the shooting industry to account. By extending the ‘close’ season, they are denying their role in this process. Worse still, they are blocking effective conservation action just to enable those who enjoy killing to carry on killing.
Evading accountability is bad enough, but they have somehow spun themselves as the hero of this story. While most rational people would remove a critically endangered bird from a hunting list, they are citing the precautionary principle. Thus implying that shooting for less time goes above and beyond what evidence suggests.
This virtue signalling by the Government could signal the end to yet another species at the hands of the shooting industry.
The Wonderful Woodcock
Everyone knows and loves the woodcock, but you probably haven’t seen one. They are a BoCC5 Red Listed species (3) in the UK and Wales and, according to the consultation, are classified as vulnerable to extinction on the GB IUCN Red List. It states that "the number of breeding males in England is estimated to have declined overall by 22.5% between 2003 and 2023. The Welsh breeding population declined by 36% over the same survey periods. There are no reliable trend estimates for the UK or Welsh non-breeding population.”

England, Scotland and Wales have all suggested extending the close season. This does not mean that fewer birds will be shot. Hunters may hunt for twice as long in a reduced hunting season and could shoot twice as many birds. So an extended close season means nothing.
The Governments’ logic is that “this should minimise the likelihood of any shot birds being rare, British breeding residents, since a much greater proportion of the woodcock population present in Britain at this time of year will be migrant birds” (4).
So we can all feel comfortable that our xenophobic policies will simply kill migrant woodcocks and not resident woodcocks.
Sources
[1] Improving Protection for Huntable Wild Birds (2026) Defra. https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/improving-protection-for-huntable-wild-birds
[2] Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 - The National Archives. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1981/69/schedules
[3] Birds of Conservation Concern 5 (BoCC) (2021) British Trust for Ornithology. https://www.bto.org/sites/default/files/publications/bocc-5-a5-4pp-single-pages.pdf
[4] Consultation (2026) Protecting wild birds: Consultation on Amending the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 which allows certain species of wild birds to be killed or taken outside of their close seasons. The National Archives. https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20260602042902/https://consult.defra.gov.uk/wildlife-crime-and-management/www-gov-uk-government-consultations-greater-protec/
[5] Aebischer, Nicholas. (2019). Fifty-year trends in UK hunting bags of birds and mammals, and calibrated estimation of national bag size, using GWCT’s National Gamebag Census. European Journal of Wildlife Research. 65. 64. 10.1007/s10344-019-1299-x. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334722395_Fifty-year_trends_in_UK_hunting_bags_of_birds_and_mammals_and_calibrated_estimation_of_national_bag_size_using_GWCT's_National_Gamebag_Census
[6] Defra and Natural England failing in legal duties to protect wild birds, says OEP (2026) Office for Environmental Protection. https://www.theoep.org.uk/news/defra-and-natural-england-failing-legal-duties-protect-wild-birds-says-oep
Image 1 - Man shooting by Jake Forsher on Unsplash - https://unsplash.com/photos/a-person-holding-a-baseball-bat-xpnFyklHriA
Image 2 - Goldeneye by Marko Hankkila on Unsplash https://unsplash.com/photos/black-and-white-duck-on-water-4TqI_aZbdl4
Image 3 - Pintail by Daniil Komov on Unsplash https://unsplash.com/s/photos/pintail
Image 4 - Wikimedia Commons - Woodcock (Scolopax rusticola), Haroldswick by Mike Pennington (10th Feb 2021). Geograph - Britain and Ireland. Created at Unst. CC BY-SA-2.0 Generic.





Comments